• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Dietitians for Professional Integrity

  • Home
  • Our Team
  • Resources
    • Advocacy & Action Toolkit
    • Conflict-Free CEUs
    • Distinguished Dietitians
    • Ethical Sponsorship
    • FNCE Guides & Reports
    • Like-Minded Organizations
    • RD Resource Toolkit
    • Statements of Concern
    • Understand The Issues
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Donate
  • Search

Oct 13, 2015 Leave a Comment

How Big Soda Sabotaged a San Antonio Public Health Campaign

Over the past few months, we’ve shared details of a derailed San Antonio City Council campaign aimed at encouraging residents to decrease their intake of sugar-sweetened beverages.

The main controversy revolved around a Coca-Cola director of public affairs and communications who was added to the working group and, predictably, had all sorts of objections to the campaign.

This past weekend, the San Antonio Express-News Editorial Board shed further light on the complex and dramatic turn of events.

Highlights:

  • “It is a complex tale that started more than a year ago when [San Antonio’s] public health director became aware of data that showed a clear link between decreased sugar consumption — mostly in beverages — and decreased obesity. It evolved into an idea for a campaign to educate San Antonians about sugar in beverages. The Metropolitan Health District, the city’s public health entity, created a working group, with other community public health partners included, to come up with this campaign. But a few months into the working group’s efforts, a representative from the beverage industry — Luisa Casso, director of public affairs and communications with the Coca-Cola Co. North America Group — was added to the working group.”
  • “Emails, obtained through a public records request, show that Casso called Metro Health on April 22, 2014, asking to be a part of this effort. This was a day after an editorial appeared in this newspaper supporting Metro Health Director Thomas Schlenker’s desire to craft a campaign focusing on sugar-sweetened beverages.”
  • “Commenting on a goal of getting consumers to “pass” on sugar-sweetened drinks and choose water instead, Casso wrote, “Overall, the industry promotes moderation and the concept of ‘passing’ suggests that the products not be consumed at all.”
  • “Rudy Ruiz, who heads Interlex Communications, a firm that was helping craft the message pro bono, sits on the board of directors of the Center for Science in the Public Interest. [He] wrote an email to Michael Jacobson, executive director of the nonprofit watchdog consumer group, [in which] Ruiz wrote: “The assistant city manager says, if the industry is not comfortable with the messages then we can’t use them. So Coke is practically telling the health department what it can and can’t say and do!”
  • “Another member, who requested anonymity, couldn’t recall when it was said but that “it became clear that whatever message came out of our group had to be approved by the beverage and Coca-Cola representative.”
  • “In June 2013, then-Mayor Castro announced $1.5 million in grants from the Coca-Cola Foundation to San Antonio Sports and the San Antonio Food Bank to finance the Mobilizing Health and Fitness Resources to Neighborhoods Project.”
  • “The city’s failure to launch its own campaign was, in our view, an unacceptable abdication of duty. A soda representative simply shouldn’t have been on the working group. And if soda didn’t have a veto, it’s unclear then how its objections could tank the city campaign.”

This is a textbook example of “sitting at the table with industry” yielding disastrous results for public health. As is usual for those kinds of arrangements, industry comes out smelling like roses while the public health sector is rendered powerless.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Categories: Problematic Sponsorship, Recommended Reads Tags: Center for Science in the Pulblic Interest, Coca-Cola, conflicts of interest, policy, Rudy Ruiz, San Antonio Express News

Reader Interactions

Leave a Comment Cancel

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

sidebar

Blog Sidebar

Social Media

FacebookTwitter

Subscribe to receive our quarterly newsletter and other breaking news!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Browse by Topic

  • Academic Research
  • Advocacy
  • Distinguished Dietitians
  • Ethical Sponsorship
  • Industry Spin
  • Industry-Funded Research
  • Interviews
  • Photos
  • Problematic Sponsorship
  • Recommended Reads
  • Reports
  • Statements of Concern
  • Uncategorized

Tags

Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics American Beverage Association Andy Bellatti Big Tobacco California Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics Center for Science in the Public Interest CEUs Civil Eats Coca-Cola ConAgra conflicts of interest Corn Refiners Association FNCE front groups General Mills Global Energy Balance Network Hershey's industry-funded research junk food Kellogg Kids Eat Right Kraft Kraft Singles lobbying Marion Nestle marketing marketing to children Mars McDonald's meat industry Michele Simon moderation National Dairy Council Nestlé New York Times PepsiCo policy soda soda tax soda taxes sugar The Sugar Association Unilever World Health Organization Yoni Freedhoff

Footer

Subscribe to receive our quarterly newsletter and other breaking news!

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Recent Posts

Farewell to Our Supporters

Dear DFPI Supporters, Since February of 2013, we at Dietitians For Professional Integrity have been a voice for uplifting the registered dietitian credential at a time when corporate influences - both overt and covert Read More

Highly Processed Foods Can Negatively Impact Health

Good read from New York Times on how highly processed foods (and the ingredients in many of them) can negatively impact health by creating an imbalance in the gut microbiome. This is the future of nutrition. The fact Read More

Social Media

FacebookTwitter

RSS

  • RSS - Posts

© 2021 Dietitians for Professional Integrity